Sealants & Waterproofing

The language of joints, membranes and flashings that keep water out of buildings.

148 terms30 shop talk8 topics

This is the vocabulary of the trades that keep water on the outside of buildings: caulkers and glaziers working facades from swing stages and bosun's chairs, waterproofers rolling membranes onto foundation walls and plaza decks, masons repointing old brick, and the building envelope consultants who investigate leaks and write the specs. You hear it on scaffolds, in pre-installation meetings and over the radio between the roof and the drop crew, and read it in leak investigation reports.

Sealant talk is about geometry and movement. A good joint has backer rod or bond breaker so there is no three-sided adhesion, a width-to-depth ratio near 2 to 1, an hourglass profile from proper tooling, and a sealant whose movement capability matches the expected movement. Failures are described precisely: cohesive failure through the bead, adhesive failure off a face, or substrate failure when the surface itself tears. Field adhesion tests settle arguments about primers.

Below-grade and deck work has its own logic. Insiders talk about positive side versus negative side, blindside membranes installed against shoring before the pour, bathtub systems, hydrostatic pressure, and the difference between true waterproofing and dampproofing. Above grade, everything comes back to flashing: through-wall flashing with end dams and weeps, sill pans, counterflashing, and the shingle lap rule that every layer sheds water onto the one below. A reverse lap or a sealed-over weep is enough to make a leaker.

The field slang is blunt. Crews talk about sausages and bulk guns, rodding ahead of the gun, tooling with a spoon, band-aids over failed joints when the owner will not pay for R&R, fishmouths at membrane laps and bugholes that blow pinholes through a fluid-applied coat. The fastest way to sound like an outsider is to call a high-performance sealant caulk on a submittal.

Who talks like this

Caulkers, glaziers, waterproofers, restoration masons, building envelope consultants, facade inspectors, sealant and membrane manufacturer reps, curtain wall installers, general contractors and architects specifying the building enclosure.

Overheard on the job

Real-sounding lines from the floor, with every insider word decoded. Tap a highlighted word.

No rod in half these joints, it's everywhere, that's why they're all split down the middle.

Plain EnglishThe installer skipped the backer rod, so the sealant bonded to the back of the joint, could not stretch and tore through its middle.

on the precast came back adhesive, they skipped the , it's on the whole elevation.

Plain EnglishAdhesion tests showed the sealant peeling cleanly off the concrete because no primer was used, so every joint on that side must be cut out and resealed.

is backfilled, so it's and crystalline from the .

Plain EnglishThe outside of the foundation wall can no longer be reached, so the leak will be fixed from inside with resin injection and a crystalline coating.

has no and the are full of , no wonder it's a .

Plain EnglishThe masonry wall's internal flashing lets water run off its ends and the drainage openings are blocked, so water is getting inside.

Wrap's reverse lapped at the , cut it and lap it right or every window on the stack will leak.

Plain EnglishThe weather barrier was overlapped the wrong way at the window base, so it has to be cut and relapped so water sheds outward over the flashing.

Owner won't pay for this year, so the worst and we'll come back in spring.

Plain EnglishThere is no budget to cut out and replace the failed sealant, so the worst sections will get a sealant band over the old joints as a temporary repair.

Fill the before you spray or the concrete will outgas through the fluid-applied and you'll be chasing all week.

Plain EnglishPatch the concrete surface voids first, or trapped air will blow pinholes through the liquid membrane that then have to be found and repaired.

The glossary

All 148 terms, grouped by topic.

148 shown

Sealant Joints

15 terms

Joint types, backer materials and the geometry that lets sealant stretch without failing.

  • Backer rodalso backer, rod
    A round foam cord pushed into a joint to set sealant depth and keep the sealant from bonding to the back.
  • Band-aidalso band-aid joint, overband
    A bridge joint applied over an existing sealant joint as a repair, without removing the old material. Shop talk
  • Bond breakeralso bond breaker tape, bond-breaker tape
    A tape or material at the back of a joint that sealant will not stick to, preventing three-sided adhesion.
  • Bridge jointalso bridge seal, overband
    A band of sealant laid over the face of a joint, bonding to the surfaces on either side instead of filling the gap.
  • Cold jointalso pour joint
    The seam where one concrete pour meets a later one, a classic leak path in below-grade walls and slabs.
  • Control jointalso contraction joint, CJ
    A cut or formed groove that makes concrete or masonry crack in a straight, planned line instead of randomly.
  • Expansion jointalso movement joint, EJ
    A designed gap between building elements that lets them move with temperature, settlement and load without cracking.
  • Fillet jointalso fillet bead, angle joint
    A triangular sealant bead run into an inside corner where two surfaces meet at an angle.
  • Hourglass profilealso hourglass shape, hourglass joint
    The ideal cross-section of a sealant joint: thick at both bond faces and thinner in the middle.
  • Movement capabilityalso joint movement capability, movement class
    How far a sealant can stretch and compress, as a percentage of joint width, while keeping its seal.
  • Precompressed foamalso expanding foam tape, impregnated foam
    Impregnated open-cell foam supplied squeezed flat that slowly expands to fill and seal a joint.
  • Roddingalso rod, rod the joint
    Installing backer rod into joints ahead of the sealant crew. Shop talk
  • Three-sided adhesionalso 3-sided adhesion, three-point adhesion
    Sealant bonded to both joint faces and the back of the joint, which locks it in place so it tears when the joint moves.
  • Two-stage jointalso dual-seal joint, double seal
    A joint with an outer rain seal and an inner air seal separated by a drained cavity.
  • Width-to-depth ratioalso shape factor, W:D ratio
    The proportion between a sealant joint's width and the sealant's depth, usually targeted at about 2 to 1.

Sealant Materials

16 terms

Sealant chemistries, grades, properties and the packaging and guns crews use to apply them.

  • Bleedalso staining, bleeding
    Staining from fluids or plasticizers that migrate out of a sealant into porous stone or masonry.
  • Bulk gunalso barrel gun, sausage gun
    A barrel caulking gun filled straight from a pail or sausage rather than from a cartridge. Shop talk
  • Butylalso butyl tape, PIB
    A rubber-based sealant or tape with very low vapor transmission but little movement capability.
  • Caulkalso caulking, caulking compound
    Everyday word for any gun-applied gap filler; in the trade, a lower-movement material than a true sealant. Shop talk
  • Cutbackalso cutback asphalt
    Asphalt or coal tar that has been liquefied with petroleum solvents.
  • Modulusalso secant modulus
    How stiff a cured sealant is, meaning how much force it pulls on its bond faces when stretched.
  • Nitrile rubberalso NBR, Buna-N
    A synthetic rubber compound known for its high resistance to oils, fuels, and chemicals.
  • Non-sagalso NS, gun grade
    Describing a sealant thick enough to stay in vertical and overhead joints without slumping.
  • Painter's caulkalso acrylic latex caulk, latex caulk
    Acrylic latex caulk used to fill interior trim gaps for painting, with little movement capability. Shop talk
  • Polysulfidealso Thiokol, PS sealant
    An elastomeric sealant, usually two-part, chosen for joints exposed to fuel, chemicals or constant immersion.
  • Polyurethane sealantalso urethane, PU sealant
    A tough, paintable elastomeric sealant used widely on concrete, masonry and traffic joints.
  • Sausagealso sausage pack, foil pack
    A soft foil or film tube of sealant loaded into a barrel gun, used instead of rigid cartridges on big jobs. Shop talk
  • Sealantalso elastomeric sealant, joint sealant
    A material that fills a joint or gap to stop water and air, while accommodating movement.
  • Siliconealso silicone sealant
    A sealant with a silicon-oxygen backbone, prized for UV resistance and high movement capability.
  • Skin timealso skinning time, tooling time
    How long after application a sealant forms a surface skin, which ends the window for tooling.
  • STPEalso hybrid sealant, MS polymer
    Silyl-terminated polyether, a moisture-curing hybrid sealant that is paintable, weather-resistant and free of isocyanates.

Below-Grade & Plaza

29 terms

Foundation, blindside and deck waterproofing, membranes, protection, drainage and leak detection.

  • Bathtubalso tub, full wrap
    A fully wrapped below-grade waterproofing system that encloses the foundation like a tub. Shop talk
  • Bentonitealso bentonite clay, bentonite mat
    A sodium clay that swells into a watertight gel when wet, used in panels, mats and strips for below-grade waterproofing.
  • Blindsidealso blind-side waterproofing, pre-applied membrane
    Waterproofing installed on the shoring or soil face before the wall is poured against it.
  • Bugholesalso bug holes, blowholes
    Small surface voids in formed concrete left by trapped air bubbles against the formwork. Shop talk
  • Covealso cant, cant strip
    A rounded or angled fillet built into an inside corner so a membrane turns the corner without bridging or tearing.
  • Crack injectionalso injection, chemical grouting
    Pumping polyurethane or epoxy into a leaking concrete crack through ports to seal it from the inside.
  • Crystalline waterproofingalso crystalline admixture, crystalline coating
    A cementitious treatment whose chemicals grow insoluble crystals inside concrete pores and cracks to block water.
  • Dampproofingalso damp-proofing, dampproof coating
    A thin coating that slows soil moisture through a foundation wall but cannot resist water under pressure.
  • Detail coatalso detailing, reinforcing coat
    An extra reinforced layer of membrane at corners, cracks, drains and penetrations before the main coat goes on.
  • Drainage compositealso drain mat, drainage board
    A dimpled or ribbed plastic core with filter fabric that carries water down to drains instead of letting it sit on the membrane.
  • ELDalso electronic leak detection, vector mapping
    Electronic leak detection, using a small electric current to pinpoint breaches in a membrane.
  • Fishmouthalso fish mouth
    An open wrinkle at the edge of a membrane lap that forms a channel water can run into. Shop talk
  • Flood testalso flood testing, ponding test
    Damming a membrane area and filling it with water for a day or more to prove it does not leak.
  • Fluid-applied membranealso liquid membrane, fluid-applied waterproofing
    A liquid waterproofing applied by roller, squeegee or spray that cures into a continuous rubbery film with no laps.
  • Holidayalso pinhole, skip
    A gap, pinhole or thin spot in a membrane or coating where it fails to cover the substrate.
  • Hot mopalso hot mopping, hot-mopped pan
    Waterproofing built from layers of felt mopped down with hot asphalt, or the act of applying it. Shop talk
  • Hot rubberized asphaltalso HRA, hot rubber
    A rubber-modified asphalt melted in a kettle and squeegeed onto decks as a thick membrane with no seams.
  • Hydrostatic pressurealso hydrostatic head, head pressure
    Pressure from standing groundwater against a wall or slab, rising with the depth of water above that point.
  • A network of drainage elements designed to intercept and route groundwater away from a foundation.
  • A cementitious coating containing iron particles that expand as they oxidize to seal concrete.
  • Negative sidealso negative-side waterproofing, dry side
    The interior face of a wall or slab, opposite the water, where waterproofing must resist water pushing it off.
  • Peel-and-stickalso self-adhered membrane, SAM
    Field name for self-adhered membrane: rubberized asphalt or butyl sheet with a release liner on the back. Shop talk
  • Plaza deckalso podium deck
    A waterproofed structural slab over occupied space, topped with pavers, soil, planters or a wearing slab.
  • Positive sidealso positive-side waterproofing, wet side
    The face of a wall or slab that touches the water source, where waterproofing works best.
  • Protection boardalso protection course, prot board
    A rigid sheet laid over a finished membrane so backfill, rebar and foot traffic cannot puncture it.
  • Sheet membranealso sheet waterproofing, roll membrane
    Waterproofing supplied in rolls of factory-made sheet with a controlled thickness, joined at overlapping laps.
  • Stick clipalso insulation pin, spindle anchor
    A self-adhering fastener used to hold drainage boards or insulation against a waterproofing membrane without puncturing it.
  • Termination baralso term bar
    A flat metal or plastic strip fastened along the top edge of a membrane to clamp it to the wall.
  • Waterstopalso water stop
    A strip cast into concrete joints to block water from traveling along the joint plane.

Flashing & Drainage

20 terms

Flashings, laps, weeps, barriers and wall designs that collect water and send it back outside.

  • The primary membrane plies that transition a roof system up a vertical surface.
  • Bootalso pipe boot, penetration boot
    A preformed or field-built collar that seals a pipe, rod or conduit where it passes through a membrane. Shop talk
  • The metal transitional components that seal a roof around a masonry chimney.
  • Counterflashingalso counter flashing, cap flashing
    Flashing set into the wall above a base flashing, overlapping it downward to shed water off its top edge.
  • Dog earalso dog-eared corner, folded corner
    A corner of flashing or membrane folded into shape without cutting, so the corner stays watertight. Shop talk
  • End damalso end dams, dam
    An upturned end at the termination of a flashing that stops water from running off the end into the wall.
  • Flashingalso flash, flashings
    Thin sheet metal or membrane installed at joints and interruptions in a wall or roof to direct water back outside.
  • Flashing collaralso roof jack, flashing boot
    A preformed or field-fabricated sleeve that seals a pipe penetration against a roof or deck.
  • Mortar droppingsalso droppings, cavity debris
    Mortar that falls into a masonry cavity during laying and piles up on the flashing, blocking drainage. Shop talk
  • A design and construction condition ensuring that all water flows away from surfaces and drains completely within 48 hours.
  • Ragglealso reglet groove
    A groove cut into a masonry or concrete wall to receive the top edge of a metal flashing.
  • Rainscreenalso rain screen, drained and back-ventilated cladding
    A wall design with cladding held off the WRB by a vented, drained gap so water can escape and the wall can dry.
  • Reverse lapalso reverse-lapped, wrong-way lap
    A lap installed the wrong way, with the lower layer over the upper, so water is channeled behind it. Shop talk
  • Shingle lapalso shingle-lapped, shingling
    Overlapping layers so each upper piece lies over the one below, sending water down and out like roof shingles.
  • Sill panalso pan flashing, sill flashing
    A tray of flashing under a window or door with a raised back and ends, catching any water that gets past the unit.
  • Strip-inalso strip in, stripping in
    To seal the flange of a flashing or fixture to the surrounding membrane with an overlapping strip of tape or sheet. Shop talk
  • A built-in depression around a roof drain that accelerates water flow and prevents ponding.
  • Through-wall flashingalso TWF, thru-wall flashing
    Flashing that runs from the back of a masonry cavity out through the wall face to drain water outside.
  • Weepalso weep hole, weeps
    An opening at the base of a wall or window system that lets collected water drain out.
  • WRBalso water-resistive barrier, building wrap
    Water-resistive barrier, the layer behind cladding that sheds water that gets past the outer skin.

Glazing & Restoration

17 terms

Glass setting, curtain wall seals, masonry repair and the access and repair methods of facade work.

  • Bosun's chairalso bosun chair, boatswain's chair
    A single-person seat suspended from roof rigging, used by caulkers and restoration workers on facades. Shop talk
  • Cap beadalso cap seal, capping bead
    A sealant bead on the outside face of the glass where it meets the stop or frame, sealing the glazing pocket from rain.
  • A non-load-bearing exterior wall of glass and metal framing hung off the building structure floor by floor.
  • Dropalso drops, stage drop
    A vertical strip of facade worked from top to bottom on one setup of a swing stage or bosun's chair. Shop talk
  • Dutchmanalso dutchman repair, inset repair
    A patch of new stone, brick or wood cut and set into a damaged area of an original piece. Shop talk
  • Efflorescencealso bloom, salt bloom
    White crystalline salt deposits left on masonry or concrete as water moving through it evaporates.
  • Heel beadalso heel seal, heel bead seal
    A sealant bead at the inside edge of the glass where it meets the frame, forming a continuous air and water seal.
  • IGUalso insulating glass, IG unit
    Insulating glass unit, two or more lites sealed around a spacer with a dry air or gas space between.
  • Litealso light, pane
    A single pane or unit of glass in a window, door or curtain wall opening.
  • R&Ralso remove and replace, cut out and reseal
    Remove and replace: cutting out old sealant completely and installing new sealant in the cleaned joint. Shop talk
  • Repointingalso pointing, repoint
    Raking out deteriorated mortar joints in masonry and refilling them with new mortar.
  • Setting blockalso setting blocks, glazing block
    A small rubber block under the bottom edge of the glass that carries its weight and keeps it off the frame.
  • Spallingalso spall, spalled concrete
    Concrete, brick or stone breaking off in flakes or chunks at the surface.
  • SSGalso structural glazing, structural silicone
    Structural silicone glazing, where glass is held to its frame by silicone instead of exterior caps or stops.
  • Tuckpointingalso tuck pointing, tuckpoint
    Common trade name for repointing brick, though strictly it is a decorative technique with a contrasting thin joint line. Shop talk
  • Water repellentalso penetrating sealer, water repellant
    A clear penetrating treatment that makes masonry and concrete shed rain while still letting vapor out.
  • Wet glazingalso wet seal, wet-glazed
    Sealing glass into its frame with gun-applied sealant instead of preformed rubber gaskets.

Testing & Failure

15 terms

Field and lab tests, mock-ups and the ways sealants and membranes break down.

  • Adhesive failurealso adhesion loss, adhesion failure
    A sealant pulling cleanly away from one joint face, leaving the substrate bare.
  • Alligatoringalso alligator cracking
    A pattern of surface cracks on aged sealant or asphalt that looks like alligator skin.
  • A raised, trapped pocket of air or moisture vapor within a roof membrane.
  • Cohesive failurealso cohesive tear, cohesive split
    A sealant tearing apart within itself while staying stuck to both joint faces.
  • Compatibility testalso compatibility testing, C1087
    A lab check that a sealant and the materials it touches do not react, discolor or lose adhesion together.
  • Field adhesion testalso pull test, cut-and-pull test
    A test that cuts a tab of cured sealant from an installed joint and pulls it to see whether it lets go of the substrate.
  • Hose testalso water test, spray test
    A field water test spraying a controlled stream from a calibrated nozzle at joints and windows to find leaks. Shop talk
  • Leakeralso leaking unit
    Any window, joint or unit that is letting water in, as tracked on a leak investigation punch list. Shop talk
  • Mock-upalso mockup
    A full-size sample of a wall, window or joint assembly built and tested before the real work starts.
  • Moisture scanalso roof scan, infrared scan
    A non-destructive survey used to locate trapped water within a roof assembly or wall system.
  • A network of deep, intersecting surface cracks in a coating or sealant that looks like dried earth.
  • Nuclear hydrogen detection meteralso nuclear moisture gauge, nuclear meter
    A diagnostic tool that uses a radioactive source to find trapped water in a roof assembly.
  • Outgassingalso out-gassing, gassing
    Gas escaping into curing sealant or membrane from punctured rod or damp concrete, leaving bubbles and pinholes.
  • Reversionalso reverting
    Cured sealant breaking down and turning soft, sticky or gooey again with heat, sun or chemical attack.
  • Substrate failurealso substrate cohesive failure
    The joint face itself breaking, so sealant comes away with a skin of concrete, coating or EIFS still attached.

Prep & Application

12 terms

Surface preparation, priming, tooling and removal steps that decide whether the work lasts.

  • To press a freshly laid membrane into its adhesive using a stiff push broom. Shop talk
  • CSPalso concrete surface profile, surface profile
    Concrete surface profile, a 1 to 10 scale of how rough a prepared concrete surface is.
  • Dry toolingalso dry tool
    Tooling sealant without water, soap or solvent on the tool, as most manufacturers require.
  • The period required for a wet-applied material to lose its volatile components and resist weather damage.
  • Fly-inalso fly in
    To embed a dry sheet membrane into a freshly applied layer of adhesive or hot bitumen. Shop talk
  • Laitancealso cement skin, weak surface layer
    A weak, powdery skin of cement and fines on the surface of concrete that sealants and membranes cannot hold onto.
  • Primeralso sealant primer, membrane primer
    A thin liquid brushed or wiped onto a joint face or deck so the sealant or membrane bonds reliably.
  • Rackingalso straight up application
    An installation method where roofing materials are applied vertically up the slope rather than horizontally.
  • Rake-outalso raking out, cut-out
    Cutting and clearing old sealant or mortar out of a joint so it can be refilled. Shop talk
  • Spoonalso tooling spoon
    Caulker's word for a tooling tool, often an actual bent spoon or a spoon-shaped steel blade. Shop talk
  • Toolingalso tool
    Pressing and shaping freshly applied sealant with a tool to force it against the joint faces and give it a neat profile.
  • Two-rag wipealso two-cloth wipe, two-cloth method
    Cleaning a joint face with a solvent-wet cloth followed immediately by a dry cloth, before the solvent evaporates.

Membrane Roofing

24 terms

Single-ply sheets, liquid-applied systems, seam welding, insulation and the fastening methods used on flat roofs.

  • Aggregatealso ballast, river rock
    Crushed stone, slag, or gravel spread over a built-up roof membrane.
  • The foundational first layer of felt or membrane in a multi-ply roof system.
  • The topmost layer of a multi-ply roofing system that protects the underlying membrane from weather and traffic.
  • A rigid roofing insulation panel made by factory-bonding two different materials together.
  • A thin, rigid board installed over roof insulation to protect it and provide a solid substrate.
  • Fallbackalso refluxing
    A chemical breakdown that lowers the softening point of heated bitumen.
  • A joint between two overlapping membrane sheets created on the job site.
  • Fleecealso fleece backing
    A non-woven fabric backing applied to sheet membranes to improve adhesion or act as a separator.
  • Glass feltalso fiberglass felt, glass mat
    A thin, non-woven mat of fiberglass strands used as a reinforcement layer in bituminous roofing.
  • A thin layer of bitumen applied to protect exposed roof plies during a delay in construction.
  • Hand-tabalso hand-seal
    To manually apply spots of roofing cement under shingle tabs to improve wind resistance.
  • Modified bitumenalso mod-bit
    A roofing membrane made of asphalt mixed with rubber or plastic polymers for flexibility and strength.
  • A random, winding ridge that forms in a roofing membrane. Shop talk
  • An installation method where a board or sheet is coated with adhesive upside down before being flipped into place. Shop talk
  • A rough, pebbled finish on sprayed polyurethane foam caused by wind carrying the material beyond the target area.
  • A grid-like pattern of ridges visible on a roof surface that outlines the insulation boards underneath.
  • PMRalso protected membrane roof, IRMA roof
    A roofing assembly where the rigid insulation is placed above the waterproofing layer.
  • Pondingalso standing water
    The accumulation of standing water on a flat roof that fails to drain or evaporate within 48 hours.
  • Protected membrane roofalso inverted roof assembly, IRMA roof
    A roofing assembly where the waterproofing membrane is installed under the thermal insulation and ballast.
  • An upward-curled edge or lap in a roofing membrane that fails to lay flat. Shop talk
  • A flexible sheet of compounded synthetic materials used as the primary waterproofing layer on flat roofs.
  • A roofing system that relies on a single layer of flexible synthetic membrane to provide waterproofing.
  • A small bubble in the top coat of a built-up roof caused by trapped moisture or gas.
  • Torch-downalso torch-applied
    A roofing method where modified bitumen sheets are melted onto the substrate using an open flame.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between caulk and sealant?

In everyday speech they are the same thing, but the trade separates them. Caulk usually means low-movement products such as acrylic latex for interior trim and small gaps. Sealant means a high-performance elastomer, such as silicone, polyurethane or a silyl-terminated polymer, rated for joint movement under ASTM C920. Specifications and submittals for building joints call for sealant, and calling it caulk can get a submittal rejected.

What is backer rod for in a sealant joint?

Backer rod is a round foam cord pressed into the joint before sealing. It sets the sealant depth, gives a firm surface to tool against, and stops the sealant from bonding to the back of the joint, which would cause three-sided adhesion. It is sized about 25 percent wider than the joint. Closed-cell rod must not be punctured, or it releases gas that bubbles the sealant.

What is three-sided adhesion and why is it bad?

Three-sided adhesion is sealant stuck to both joint faces and to the back of the joint. A working sealant must stretch across its full width, but bonded at the back it cannot, so stress concentrates and it tears or pulls off within a few movement cycles. Backer rod or bond breaker tape prevents it by giving the sealant something it will not stick to.

What is the difference between positive-side and negative-side waterproofing?

Positive-side waterproofing goes on the face of the wall or slab that touches the water, usually the soil side, where water pressure pushes the membrane onto the structure. Negative-side waterproofing goes on the interior face, opposite the water, and must resist pressure from behind. Only materials that bond into the concrete, like crystalline and cementitious coatings, work well on the negative side.

How is a sealant pull test done?

For the cut-and-pull field adhesion test, the inspector slices across the cured bead, runs a 3-inch cut down each bond line to free a tail, then peels the tail back at 90 degrees. If the sealant tears within itself or stretches a set distance before releasing, adhesion is good. If it peels cleanly off a face, the primer or preparation is wrong. The test spot is resealed afterward.

Every entry is checked by people who use the words.

Terms are validated with working professionals and approved by our editorial committee before they are published. See how a word earns its place.

Our editorial process